Friday, December 01, 2006

Gathering in Solidarity

I took picket captain training yesterday at BUFA Strike HQ. It was a long afternoon of instruction in how to apply common sense to a sometimes difficult, potentially volatile situation. The repeated mantra of "Safety, safety, safety!" drove home the reality of the course upon which we may have to embark. This will be an unpleasant, uncomfortable, by necessity adversarial exercise.

I often do a mental run-through of the chronology of the negotiations that have taken place in the last 8 months and I always reach a point where it seems logical to me that this job action could have been averted. BUFA offered to consider arbitration on monetary issues if the non-monetary items could be settled through negotiation. This was BUFA's olive branch, our way of saying that WE WANT AN AGREEMENT, NOT A STRIKE.

The administration refused arbitration, even though the decision on salaries could have been to their advantage.

For some reason, I can't shake the feeling that faculty members have been forced deliberately and cynically onto the road to a strike, with all the tension, frustration, despair, and plummeting morale that comes with a strike.

And I can't help feeling that this behaviour is intended to influence not only the agreement that is on the table now, but also to set the tone for the next agreement to be negotiated 2-3 years from now.

If this is the case, I think the administration has badly misread the membership.

At the General Membership Meeting following the training for picket captains, the turnout was heavy and the mood was grim.

Each of us there knew only too well that the veil of change had fallen over Brock. With this pall hanging over the gathering, the new president's calls to collegiality, as late as the e-mail of November 29, seemed sterile and empty to most seated in the Brock Ballroom of the Four Points Sheraton .

As I circulated the room with my coffee, colleague after colleague volunteered comments on the distinct change and observed that the administration's behaviour towards negotiations was anything but collegial. This was an emergent leitmotif so strong that it was like reading Thomas Mann.

The meeting got underway and the cohesive spirit in the room was palpable. The membership had closed ranks and it was remarkable. Dignified determination fueled by the hurt of betrayal is the best way that I can verbalize what I felt coursing through the meeting.


We have fine, fine leadership in Barry Grant and the Executive.
Thank you.


We have a determined, patient, and dedicated Negotiating Team in Terry Carroll, Chief Negotiator, Don Dworet, Tom Jenkyns, Linda Lowry, Carol Sales, and Kimberly Benoit.
Thank you.


We have an active, organized Strike Action Committee chaired by Miriam Richards.
Thank you.


We have a united, committed Membership.
I am happy to be counted among your ranks.



As a young man, I was taught by my Chinese-Canadian father to avoid fighting at school, to use words as my defence.

"If they call you Chink, ask them if being born in Canada means you are not Canadian like them"

"If they call you egghead, ask them if that is worse than being ignorant."
But my father also warned me that sometimes talking just doesn't work.

Sometimes you just have to stand your ground and fight.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

"BUFA offered to consider arbitration on monetary issues if the non-monetary items could be settled through negotiation. This was BUFA's olive branch, our way of saying that WE WANT AN AGREEMENT, NOT A STRIKE"

Actually, this says: "We don't care about the issues which directly affect students, we only care about the MONEY." Do you honestly think that students are so ignorant to believe that BUFA has voted for a strike to benefit students? I don't think so.

Perhaps your father forgot to teach you this lesson when you were young: You should never complain about your employer for they provide you with a paycheque. If you don't like your job or the salary it provides then look elsewhere. BUFA decides to seek pity from students because they are not going to get a paycheque so close to Christmas? I'm sorry, but who voted to strike? Professors are claiming that "students have changed"? What about the professors? I have been a student at this University for the last three years and I can tell you that every ounce of respect I once held for my professors has diminished to near nothing. We are simply pawns in your chess game.

I've been following your blog every day. At times I become very frustrated with the childish behaviour. Other times, I can't help myself and I must laugh.

Bottom line: YOU chose the strike and now YOU have to deal with it.

I know that this comment will not be approved. This is what I say to that:

"TALK/DON'T TELL"

Anonymous said...

Actually, 'anonymous', you've got that wrong. If the non-money issues are settled (important matters such as who decides promotions, when faculty get tenure, and how many part-time lecturers are hired), BUFA is agreeing to return to work and let an arbitrator decide the money issues.

While this may show confidence in their monetary claims, it also shows that they are not letting money stand in the way of going back to work.

Anonymous said...

Your quite something anonymous, fortunatly for most of history ordinary people have ignored your advice to 'do what your told and be grateful for the crumbs'. Probably once you get a job you will as well but a word of advice - don't let your future employer in on your your 'wisdom' until you've had a chance to get some experience in.

The students are unfortunate in that they are caught in the middle but one day they will grow up and get jobs too. I reckon then those who don't yet understand why sometimes you have to stand up will find out soon enough. And then they might realise they learned something valuable that wasn't on the curriculum.

Andrew Fleming

Anonymous said...

Dear 'Anonymous',
Perhaps you should re-read the sentence:
"BUFA offered to consider arbitration on monetary issues if the non-monetary items could be settled through negotiation."

Now, some more comments.
While it is true that students are the unfortunate victims to the Brock War, how could you think that one party is to blame? In-action is an action by itself.
Stop and think of the 'acting' party(ies), and the party(ies) that arent doing anything.
Stop and think of how many parties are involved in this whole matter.
Administration, Students, Faculties. These parties are then divided into several more parties.
- Students with opinions but who chose not to voice them
- Students with no opinion
- Students with opinions and chose to voice them (sit-in, compromise campaign)
- Faculties who stood up for the strike
- Faculties who do not wish for a strike but did not vote 'NO' to strike vote
- etc

If you consider the many parties and their contribution (or lack of) to the current situation, you have to agree that one party alone isnt to blame.

Furthermore, while I do not necessarily agree with the standpoint of the faculties, i do believe that here is a lifelong lesson that has stood the ages: Stand up for what you believe, because, NO ONE ELSE will do that for you, if you wont do it yourself. I can prove this statement right now: You believe that the actions of these faculties are hurting the students.
However, have you considered that these faculties believes that they are being hurt by the administration? If they do not stand for themselves, are you going to do that for them? In the end, you are looking out for yourself, and why should you be the judge when some other people decided that they will look out for themselves?

Lastly, in terms of your views on professors:
Let me make it clear to you, that whatever degree that they might have, professors are human, and will act as such. Which means that, from any given group of people, you will find some that you will like, and some that you dont.
In my years of university, i have, as you said, found professors who, for lack of better words, are unable to 'communicate' with their students. Whatever the numbers of these professors are, I have found professors who 'can' communicate with students. I can hardly believe that it is a reflection of Brock professors if you havent been able to find a single professor in the past 3 years that can leave a mark in your heart.

Perhaps you should take a class with professor barry joe, before judging him for being human in his own blog.